The Realities of Ramadan in Prison
Ramadan should be a joyous time for Muslim people around the world, but for those in prison it can be a particularly difficult and isolating period.
Added to this, due to the Covid-19 pandemic people in prison have had a year of being confined to small cells for over 23 hours a day, with little interaction with others and in most cases having had no visits from outside prisons.
After a year of this forced isolation, and with prisons still under severe lockdown, we have a prison population that is mentally and physically fragile and disconnected from communities outside of the prison system.
This combined with the discrimination Muslim people in prison face, the disregard for their religion and the practical difficulties of observing Ramadan in a prison environment will make Ramadan an even more challenging time this year.
The experience of Muslims in prison during Ramadan are not normally given a public hearing. Our work over Ramadan aims to end this silencing of their experiences. Through a series of audios and comics we shine a light on the discrimination that Muslims in prison face during this important time.
Fasting and praying around prison regimes
About this clip
A Muslim man describes the abuse and discrimination he faced as he is aggressively challenged by a prison officer to wake up despite prior arrangements to allow him to sleep in.
Muslim people in prison are entitled to fast and pray during Ramadan. It means they may stay up late to pray and get up early to eat before sunrise. They can therefore be excused from having to wake up at breakfast times with other prisoners. However this is ultimately left up to the prison officer to decide.
The abuse this man receives is a stark contrast to the treatment a fellow white prisoner receives a week later. He goes on to get accused of having a ‘bad attitude’, a stereotype that Black and Brown people are all too used to having levelled at them whenever they disagree with the way they are treated.
Access to food for breaking fasts
About this clip
Muslims fasting during Ramadan should be provided with food by the prison outside of the usual mealtimes. Hot food in flasks or boxes should be given in the evening to be eating after sunset, along with breakfast packs for the morning meal before sunrise.
However, in this clip a Muslim man talks about how the boxes can arrive with food missing or completely empty because those working in the kitchen have taken from them. It can be difficult to resolve this because by the time someone goes to eat their food it is after they have been locked in their cells.
This man goes on to share, in a stark example of the bullying and targeted abuse that can be experienced in prison, a disturbing time where one Muslim man was victim to someone putting excrement in their food box.
He goes on to talk about how difficult it can be to raise a complaint, receiving dismissive responses in reply that don’t address the root problems of the issues arising. It highlights how the complaints process is a performative gesture that does not provide true accountability.
Waking up before sunrise
About this clip
Timekeeping is an essential element of Ramadan so that you know when to begin and end your fast. But like so many aspects across the prison estate, inconsistency proves to be the problem.
Whether alarm clocks are allowed, whether they are provided or available to purchase on canteen sheets, and the price of them varies across the prison estate.
Alternatively, prison officers may assist with waking people so they can eat before sunrise. But this relies on the discretion of individual officers. This clip shows the response from a Muslim man with experience of prison when we asked him about this. He highlights how much this support can vary in different prisons.
Some officers make a dedicated effort to note everyone who needs waking up, but in other prisons that understanding and support isn’t there with officers telling him they forgot. This inconsistency is enabled by a lack of process and creates a postcode lottery.
This man’s experience shows that it is possible to provide the support. But it shouldn’t be reliant on individual officers having the commitment, understanding & time to create their own process for this. It can too easily lead to Muslims being denied the right to observe their religion.
Every prison should have a process for noting down those who need support waking up and ensuring a member of staff does this or consistent provision of alarm clocks.
Maintaining contact with loved ones
About this clip
Prison is an isolating and lonely experience. It disrupts family and community ties and makes it incredibly difficult to maintain meaningful contact. In this audio clip, a Muslim man describes the impact on mental health when you can’t see your loved ones and how it can be more challenging to get through your sentence without that support network.
The treatment of visitors can make it harder for loved ones to visit and puts them in uncomfortable positions. He describes a time his partner was made to remove her headscarf.
During Ramadan there is usually an emphasis on giving to others and togetherness. Meals are often spent with families and friends and many people visit the Mosque more often, spending more time with their local communities.
For prisoners, being cut off from that and the lack of contact with loved ones during this time can make the isolation and loneliness of prison feel particularly acute. Lockdown conditions only exacerbate this with people locked in their cells for over 23 hours a day and visits cancelled. Short phone calls and video visits - or even in-person ones - can’t ever hope to replace the connections and experiences in the community.
Credits:
Illustrations by Hannah Berry.
With thanks to those we interviewed for giving us their time and sharing their incredible insights.
More about this project
Whilst every Muslim person in prison has the right to observe Ramadan, our research, Time to End the Silence, shows that inconsistent provisions, a lack of basic religious and cultural understanding about Islam, and outright discrimination creates barriers for Muslims practicing their religion.
These include:
Fasting: Access to quality food during Ramadan, as eating times are outside of the usual prison regime hours, is challenging with many accounts of food being cold, food being tampered with, or being taken before its able to reach Muslim prisoners.
Timekeeping: Inconsistent provision of alarm clocks leads many Muslims having to rely on prison officers to help them with waking up to eat before sunrise. Owing to the lack of recognition about the importance of this to Muslim people it can lead to a disregard by some officers and a failure to support them with this.
Sharing cells: Sharing cells during Ramadan with non-Muslim people can create greater conflict when Muslims may have to stay up late praying, pray more or get up early to eat before sunrise making them vulnerable to experiencing greater levels of abuse.
Health: Mental and physical health has deteriorated over the last year as a result of Covid-19 lockdown leading to concerns about the impact on those fasting.
Mental health, isolation, and loneliness
In addition to the stress and anxiety that all this can cause, Ramadan is also a time where the isolation and loneliness of prison can feel especially sharp. Cut off from families, friends and communities during a time that would usually be spent with others.
During Covid-19 lockdown, this is particularly acute with no social visits allowed and only short phone or video calls taking place. Added to this, the informal support networks between Muslim people in prison and gatherings that would usually be arranged by prison Imams – that could usually provide a coping mechanism during this time - have been cut off to a large extent as well by confining people to cells.
What we did
We held a number of interviews with Muslim people currently in prison or who had recently been to prison.
Throughout Ramadan we’ll be releasing a series of audio clips from these interviews that give voice to the experiences of Muslim people in prison in their own words and show how they have been prevented from fully exercising their right to observe Ramadan. Each clip is accompanied by comic panels which illustrate what they’ve endured during in Ramadan.